"You're One to Talk": How Whataboutism Shuts Down Feedback in Your Retrospectives
In the retrospective, someone brings up the valuable point that "I don't think we're testing enough before deploying." The reply doesn't address the idea: "And what about you, who never update the board?" The criticism is left hanging, the team gets caught up in egos, and the original problem remains untouched. It's a tactic as old as rhetoric (very common in childhood), and it has a quiet way of emptying our conversations. Let's talk about why it appears, what it does to a team, and what we can do about it.