STRIPS by Scrum Manager
← All strips

A Dictated Diagnosis Is No Diagnosis

A Scrum Manager strip

Four-panel comic strip in a meeting room: the team's assessor, standing by a whiteboard, sets an anonymous survey from 0 to 3 on whether they feel free to say what they think; the manager stands behind the two respondents, looking over their shoulders, and tells them to take their time; two threes appear on the whiteboard and the manager celebrates with his arms raised while the two respondents look at him unsmiling; the assessor writes MONDAY on the whiteboard and tells him they will do it again on Monday, without him in the room, and the respondents look relieved.
The concept

A diagnosis is only useful if it captures what is really happening, and that depends on people being able to answer honestly. Survey answers are always subjective and easily distorted: the pressure of the company culture — or of the person in charge, looking over everyone's shoulder — is enough for everyone to answer what they expect the others want to hear. That is why assessment surveys are anonymous, why their purpose and what is expected of them are explained beforehand, and why their results are treated as raw data to be calibrated against direct observation of day-to-day work. When the conditions of the measurement condition the answers, what gets measured is the pressure, not the agility. A dictated diagnosis is no diagnosis: before measuring, make sure people can answer freely.

Want to keep pulling the thread? This topic unfolds in Agilevel (v 5.0) > Introduction > Surveys and weighting.

Share this strip

Copy link X LinkedIn
Get them by email →