Professional

Leading in Uncertain Times: When Not Having All the Answers Is Part of the Role

Automatic translation · View original

Topic illustration: Leading in Uncertain Times: When Not Having All the Answers Is Part of the Role

There are conversations that come up more and more often in teams: someone senses that something isn't right, but their manager projects confidence and calm. The result isn't reassurance but bewilderment. "Am I getting this wrong? Why do I feel this way if they tell me everything is fine?" Unresolved uncertainty that someone tries to hide doesn't disappear; it turns into rumors and disconnection between those who lead and those who do the work. Is there a way to eliminate uncertainty? Or, rather, is there a way to lead through uncertainty without losing the team's trust and cohesion?

The image of leadership that has prevailed for a long time has been very specific: a confident person who has an answer for every question and conveys certainty even when they don't have it. However, it is not a realistic image, nor should it be.

The pandemic, the arrival of generative artificial intelligence in workflows, market volatility, and geopolitical complexity have turned uncertainty into the permanent backdrop of most organizations. And in that context, the image of the omniscient leader stops working and becomes actively harmful.

Ronald Heifetz and Marty Linsky, in their work on adaptive leadership, have for years distinguished between technical problems and adaptive challenges: the former have known solutions that someone with sufficient expertise can apply; the latter require the organization itself to change: its beliefs, its habits, its way of understanding work. And the most common trap, according to Heifetz, is treating adaptive challenges as if they were technical problems. That is, looking for the expert answer when what is needed is collective exploration capacity.

Today, with the factors and changes that generate uncertainty, the cultural pressure on those who lead remains the pressure to appear confident.

The Cost of Well-Intentioned Silence

There is an understandable temptation when leading through difficult moments: protecting the team from anxiety by filtering information, rationing it, or simply waiting for more clarity before communicating. The intention is good. The effect, usually, is the opposite.

Amy Edmondson has extensively documented how teams need not only psychological safety to talk about their mistakes or propose ideas; they also need it to tolerate and process uncertainty collectively. When information is scarce, teams don't stay calm: they fill the gaps with the most available narratives. It is a well-studied cognitive mechanism: faced with ambiguity, the brain tends to anticipate the worst possible scenario as a protective mechanism.

Silence, in this sense, is not neutrality. It is a message. And that message, as interpreted by the team, is usually: something is wrong and they don't want to tell us.

This doesn't mean leaders must share all information in real time or unload their own anxieties onto the team. There is an important difference between transparency and emotional offloading. The former builds trust. The latter can destabilize. The challenge is finding the balance point: communicating what is known, acknowledging what is not known, and giving a timeframe for when more clarity will come.

Something as concrete as "we don't have a final decision yet, but we hope to share more information before the end of the month" has a significant psychological effect. It doesn't resolve the uncertainty, but it contains it. And this is a form of leadership that we often undervalue.

Emotions in the Role

One of the most complex aspects of leadership in turbulent times has to do with the management of one's own emotions. The image of the unflappable leader, capable of facing any storm without flinching, is so deeply internalized that many leaders feel that showing any form of concern is a sign of weakness or incompetence.

Liz Fosslien has explored precisely this tension. Some people step into leadership positions with the conviction that they must have all the answers from day one. And when reality shows that this is not possible, a dissonance appears: optimism is conveyed to the team while internally they manage an anxiety that has no outlet. The team perceives it even if they can't name it, and that perception generates distrust.

Research on emotional intelligence in leadership points in a consistent direction: leaders who select and share emotions in a contextually appropriate way (emotional regulation) build more cohesive and resilient teams than those who systematically suppress every emotional signal.

Selecting and sharing is not the same as showing everything. It is an active practice: identifying which emotions are useful for the team at this moment and which only add noise. Acknowledging that a situation is difficult, that it generates uncertainty, or that the leader is also navigating without a complete map can, paradoxically, strengthen authority rather than erode it. Because it normalizes the team's experience and eliminates the dissonance between what is said and what is perceived.

AI: An Additional Layer of Uncertainty

We cannot talk about leadership in uncertain times without mentioning generative artificial intelligence. Over the last two years, few organizations have been able to stay untouched by the question of what this means for their teams, their processes, and their business models.

Many workers and leaders recognize that AI is changing the way they work (not necessarily in a positive way), but most organizations have not yet developed clear strategies to manage that transformation. That gap between the speed of technological change and the organizational capacity to process it is, in itself, a massive source of anxiety.

What does the team expect from its leader in this context? Not necessarily that they have all the answers about how AI will transform their sector. That would be asking the impossible. Rather, they expect leadership to acknowledge the question and create space to explore it collectively.

Technological acceleration has made tolerance for ambiguity a leadership competence as critical as strategic vision or execution capability. Edgar Schein already pointed out that leaders model, more than anyone, the relationship an organization has with the unknown. If the leader avoids or denies ambiguity, the organization learns to do the same. If they face it with curiosity and epistemic humility, they create the conditions for others to do so as well.

Clarity Without Omniscience

Acknowledging that you don't have all the answers does not mean disappearing from the role. There are concrete ways of exercising leadership that do not require certainty about the future but do require commitment to the team's present.

  • Investing in people's growth is one of the few things a leader can offer regardless of the external context. It is not always possible to guarantee a promotion or, in certain circumstances, even a long-term job. But one can actively invest in developing capabilities that are valuable to the person, both in their current role and in any future context. Leadership that prioritizes people's growth not only improves present performance; it gives them tools to navigate the future with more resources of their own.
  • Creating partial clarity is another fundamental lever. When the full picture is not visible, delineating what is known and what is still being defined has a stabilizing effect. This includes communicating the team's short-term priorities with precision, even if long-term ones remain vague. A team that knows what to do over the next three months can function far more effectively than one waiting for a five-year plan that no one can guarantee.
  • Providing context, even if incomplete, is preferable to waiting for the complete picture. The absence of information does not produce calm: it produces speculation. Updating the team with what is available, even if limited, and offering a time horizon for when more clarity will come, significantly reduces the cognitive and emotional noise that uncertainty generates without context.

These three axes are guidelines that each leader will have to translate into their specific context, with their team, in their organization, with their real constraints. The temptation to turn them into a checklist is understandable; however, resisting it is part of leadership maturity.

The Limits of the Individual

Not everything that generates uncertainty in a team is within the sphere of influence of the person leading it.

There are organizations whose incentive systems systematically contradict the messages of trust and collaboration they preach. There are cultures where vulnerability is punished even though the discourse proclaims it a virtue. There are restructurings decided at levels that never consult those who will have to implement them. In those contexts, asking a middle manager to "manage uncertainty with authenticity and empathy" can be a demand that fails to recognize the weight of the real constraints under which they operate.

Chris Argyris, in his work on organizational learning and espoused theories versus theories-in-use, documented this gap with precision: organizations often say they value transparency but design systems that penalize it. A leader who tries to be honest about uncertainty within a system that rewards the appearance of control takes on a personal risk that should not be ignored.

This is not an excuse for paralysis. It is a reminder that leadership in uncertain times is not only an individual competence: it is also, and often primarily, a matter of organizational design. Agile teams that work well in contexts of high uncertainty do not do so solely because of the quality of their leaders, but because their organizations have built structures and cultures that allow adaptation without punishing error or doubt.


Leading in uncertain times is not a skill acquired once and for all. It is a practice refined through conversation with oneself, with the team, and with the context. And like any practice, it improves when there is space to reflect on it, not just to carry it out.

How are you managing the tension between what you know and what you cannot share yet?

Share your experience in the comments. Sometimes the best compass in uncertain times is not a framework, but an honest conversation with someone who is also in the mud.

Bibliography

Argyris, C. (1990). Overcoming Organizational Defenses: Facilitating Organizational Learning. Prentice Hall.

Dweck, C. S. (2006). Mindset: The New Psychology of Success. Random House.

Edmondson, A. C. (2018). The Fearless Organization: Creating Psychological Safety in the Workplace for Learning, Innovation, and Growth. Wiley.

Fosslien, L. y West Duffy, M. (2019). No Hard Feelings: The Secret Power of Embracing Emotions at Work. Portfolio/Penguin.

Goleman, D., Boyatzis, R. y McKee, A. (2002). Primal Leadership: Realizing the Power of Emotional Intelligence. Harvard Business School Press.

Heifetz, R. A. y Linsky, M. (2002). Leadership on the Line: Staying Alive Through the Dangers of Leading. Harvard Business School Press.

Schein, E. H. (2010). Organizational Culture and Leadership (4.ª ed.). Jossey-Bass.

Snowden, D. J. y Boone, M. E. (2007). "A leader's framework for decision making". Harvard Business Review, 85(11), 68–76. Disponible en: https://hbr.org/2007/11/a-leaders-framework-for-decision-making

🔒 Restricted Poll

Please log in to your Scrum Manager account to do this.

Log in
Share:

Comments (2)

Log in to your Scrum Manager area to comment


Avatar
Juan Tatay Galvany ★
19 Jul 2026 19:19

I've been that way… This doesn't mean leaders should share all information in real time or offload their own anxieties onto the team. There's an important difference between transparency and emotional dumping.

I think I'm working on it

Automatic translation · View original

Reply Reactions
Scrum Manager ★★
7 Aug 2026 11:08

Nobody is born knowing how to do it, and emotional management is complex and difficult (although perhaps it would not be so complicated if we were taught it as children). Lots of encouragement on your journey! Being aware of our mistakes and possible improvements is the best step you can take to start changing.

Automatic translation · View original

Reply