Ir al contenido

Product-based financing

De Scrum Manager BoK
Esta página es una versión traducida de la página Financiación por producto. La traducción está completa al 100 %.
⏱ 5 min  ·  📅 2026
Product-based funding involves providing persistent resourcing to teams that manage a product or a value stream, and periodically reviewing that resourcing based on the evidence of value they generate—rather than allocating funds to projects with a scope, budget, and timeline defined in advance.

This is one of the decisions that most determines whether an organization truly operates by product. A company can reorganize its teams, rename its roles, and fully adopt Scrum, yet still continue to operate by project if funding continues to flow through initiatives defined by scope and a deadline.

Why project-based funding clashes with the model

  • It forces you to estimate in advance what can only be discovered through the act of doing. The budget requires a fixed scope at the very moment when your understanding of the problem is at its lowest.
  • It penalizes learning. If the approved plan serves as the benchmark, any change in direction is recorded as a deviation—even when that change stems from having learned something valuable.
  • It dissolves teams and their knowledge. When a project ends, the team is disbanded—taking with it the knowledge accumulated about the product, the users, and the codebase.

The six Scrum.org portfolio principles

In June 2025, Dave West proposed six guiding principles for portfolio management within a product model:

  • Fund products (the teams), not the work.
  • Minimize cross-product initiatives that require portfolio management.
  • Ensure that discovery, delivery, and validation take place within the product teams.
  • Define work in terms of outcomes and metrics.
  • Align incentives, structure, and governance with business and product strategy.
  • Require transparency, cadence, and clear ownership.

The first one is what gives the practice its name: the team responsible for the product receives funding, and it is this team that decides—within the scope of the product strategy—which specific work to allocate those funds to. Large-scale initiatives are not treated as fixed commitments, but rather as bets that can be revised based on evidence.

Why AI reinforces this logic

Lowering the cost of development does not weaken the argument; it reinforces it. If building becomes increasingly inexpensive, the scarce resource is no longer the capacity to produce, but rather the capacity to make sound decisions about where to continue investing. A funding model that can only approve projects with a fixed scope is, in fact, the least well-suited to address that question.

State of the practice

The principle is well-formulated, but its actual adoption is uneven. A study by Scrum.org on the barriers to a product-based operating model identifies silos and hierarchical structures as persistent obstacles; these limit team autonomy, transparency, and end-to-end ownership, alongside an inconsistent application of evidence-based decision-making.

Common errors and anti-patterns

  • Funding a product as a project. Labeling something a "product" while continuing to approve it based on scope, budget, and a fixed deadline.
  • Reviewing based on milestones rather than evidence. Checking whether the plan has been followed, instead of whether the strategic bet is actually working.
  • Reorganizing without restructuring funding. Changing team structures while leaving the flow of money untouched—the old structure inevitably re-emerges through the budgeting process.
  • Approving funds for individual initiatives within a product. This effectively replicates project-based management at a lower, less visible level.

References

Resources

🏦 Agile Product Operating ModelSkill Arena · Scrum Manager

See also

Want to advance your agility? You can look for upcoming courses and exams, or progress at your own pace by becoming a member of the Agile Club. This membership includes exclusive resources, e-learning classrooms, and access to Skill Arena: a space to practice and measure your agile skills at your own speed.