Beyond budgeting
When the same figure serves as both a target and a forecast, the forecast ceases to be honest: no one predicts a result below their goal. And when that figure also determines the following year’s budget, an incentive arises to spend the allocated funds, even if they are not actually needed.
The twelve principles
The Beyond Budgeting Institute organizes them into two blocks of six.
| Leadership principles | Management process principles |
|---|---|
| 1. Purpose | 7. Pace |
| 2. Values | 8. Objectives |
| 3. Transparency | 9. Plans and forecasts |
| 4. Organization | 10. Resource allocation |
| 5. Autonomy | 11. Performance evaluation |
| 6. Customers | 12. Rewards |
Each principle is framed as a contrast between two approaches. Some examples:
- Objectives: set directional, ambitious, and relative goals; avoid fixed, cascaded objectives.
- Rhythm: organize management processes around the rhythm and events of the business, rather than solely around the calendar year.
- Resource allocation: foster a cost-conscious mindset and make resources available as needed, instead of distributing them through a detailed annual budget.
- Rewards: reward shared success relative to the competition, rather than the fulfillment of a fixed performance contract.
Application to the product: lean budgeting
When applied to product work, this approach translates into three specific decisions: empowering persistent teams rather than individual initiatives, allocating funds over short time horizons that are reviewed based on evidence, and ensuring that the budget does not turn into a disguised commitment to a specific scope.
The transition does not require abolishing the budget all at once. The typical approach is gradual: first, separate the target from the forecast; next, revise the allocation on a cycle shorter than a year; and only then, revisit how performance is evaluated and rewarded.
Common errors and anti-patterns
- The disguised annual budget. Conducting quarterly reviews of an allocation that has, in reality, already been decided for the entire twelve-month period.
- The fixed target that also serves as the basis for rewards. As long as compensation depends on a fixed number, no one will provide an honest forecast.
- All or nothing. Framing the change as the complete abolition of the budget ensures that it will never even get started.
References
- Beyond Budgeting Institute. The 12 Beyond Budgeting Principles (2016 revision). Document at bbrt.org.